Meet Andrea

Why I Stopped Trying To Be The Expert In Every Conversation

For years, I believed being useful meant having something valuable to say in every conversation. As a broadcaster, journalist, author and public speaker, I built much of my working life around preparation. I researched the subject, anticipated the difficult question and arrived ready to contribute. Expertise became part of my professional identity, and it was easy to confuse being well prepared with needing to be right.

That habit can look impressive from the outside, especially in a studio, on a conference stage or around a boardroom table. Yet the need to demonstrate knowledge can quietly close down curiosity. I began to notice that the most meaningful conversations about leadership, resilience, wellbeing and women’s health were rarely the ones where I delivered the perfect answer. They were the ones where I listened carefully enough for somebody else’s insight to emerge.

The Cost Of Always Having The Answer

Trying to be the authority in every exchange is exhausting. It creates a private performance that continues even when nobody has asked for one. Instead of hearing what a colleague is saying, I might be preparing a response, searching for a relevant personal experience or wondering whether my next sentence will sound sufficiently informed.

That pressure is particularly familiar in public-facing work. A television broadcaster is expected to be across the facts. An event host must keep momentum moving. A keynote speaker is often introduced as someone with answers about resilience, personal growth or leadership. Those responsibilities matter, yet they do not mean I have to dominate every moment with certainty.

There is also a cost for the people around you. When someone turns every conversation into a chance to display expertise, others may stop offering unfinished ideas. A junior team member might keep quiet rather than risk being corrected. A friend may decide there is no space for their experience. A room can become polished, articulate and strangely unproductive.

I saw this most clearly when discussing women’s wellbeing. People do not always need a neat explanation of stress, burnout or confidence. Sometimes they need to say, “This is what is happening in my life,” without being immediately analysed. Listening can be a more respectful response than reaching for a framework.

What Listening Changed For Me

The turning point was not a single dramatic moment. It was a gradual recognition that my best conversations had a different rhythm. I asked more open questions, allowed pauses to remain pauses and stopped treating every silence as something I needed to fill. The result was not less authority. It was better connection.

When I speak to corporate audiences about wellbeing, I want the discussion to feel relevant to the actual people in the room, whether they work in a Sydney office, a Melbourne hospital, a Brisbane warehouse or a regional organisation managing long commutes and limited resources. My work around speaking about wellness has taught me that useful ideas must make room for different pressures, cultures and working conditions.

Australian workplaces have their own context. A team may be navigating the cost of living in Perth, a FIFO roster in Western Australia, severe weather disruption in Queensland or the intensity of end-of-financial-year deadlines. A generic lecture about balance will not land equally with everyone. Listening helps reveal what “wellbeing” means in that particular organisation, rather than assuming the same prescription fits every employee.

It has also changed how I prepare for events. I still do the research, but I now leave room for discovery. Before a panel or keynote, I want to understand the audience, the language they use and the questions they are carrying. A morning tea conversation before an event can reveal more than a polished briefing document. So can a quiet comment after the formal session has finished.

When I Lead With Expertise When I Lead With Curiosity
I focus on proving what I know I focus on understanding what is needed
I prepare a response before the person has finished I listen for the meaning behind the words
I treat uncertainty as a weakness I allow uncertainty to open a useful discussion
I offer a universal solution I consider the person, team and context
I measure success by how impressive I sound I measure success by what the conversation makes possible

Expertise Has A Place, And A Limit

Stepping back from expert mode does not mean dismissing knowledge. Facts, experience and professional skill remain essential. If I am discussing mental health, workplace wellbeing or leadership, I have a responsibility to be accurate and thoughtful. Personal stories can illuminate an issue, but they should not replace qualified advice or evidence.

The distinction is in how expertise is used. It can be an invitation into a conversation, or it can become a wall. Used well, knowledge gives people language for what they are experiencing. Used defensively, it can shut down their lived experience with a quick label or confident conclusion.

I think about this distinction when sharing stories from my own life. Speaking honestly about pressure, change and recovery has helped many people feel less alone, yet my experience is still one experience. It may create recognition, but it cannot tell another person exactly what to do. The responsible position is to share what I have learned without presenting my path as a universal map.

This is especially important when talking about women. Women are often expected to be capable, emotionally intelligent and endlessly accommodating, then criticised when they express certainty or ambition. I do not want to replace that impossible expectation with another one: the demand to know everything, fix everything and guide everyone. Empowerment includes having the confidence to say, “I don’t know,” “I need more information” or “Tell me how you see it.”

The same principle applies to public credibility. A strong media presence can create an assumption that the person in front of the audience has an answer for every subject. The reach of a platform can be useful, but reach is not the same as authority in every field. Looking at media statistics may show the scale of an audience, but meaningful communication still depends on trust, relevance and the willingness to listen.

A Better Way To Enter The Room

I now try to enter a conversation with two intentions: to contribute honestly and to remain open to being changed by what I hear. That sounds simple, but it requires discipline. The old reflex is quick. Someone mentions a challenge and I immediately connect it to a story, a book, a previous interview or a point I have made on stage.

Sometimes that connection is useful. Sometimes it is a subtle way of moving the focus back to myself. I have learned to pause before speaking and ask whether my contribution will serve the conversation or merely display my experience. That small check can change the tone of a meeting, a podcast interview or a personal exchange.

In practical terms, I listen for three layers. First, what are the actual words? Second, what emotion or concern sits underneath them? Third, what has not yet been said because the person may not feel safe enough to say it? The third layer is where patience matters. People often need time to find the honest version of their thought.

This approach is valuable in Australian business settings, where communication is often direct but hierarchy still shapes who speaks. A relaxed tone, a shared flat white and a quick joke can make a meeting feel informal, yet a graduate or new employee may still hesitate to challenge a senior leader. Inviting contributions is different from creating genuine permission to disagree. The leader has to listen without immediately defending the existing plan.

I have also become more comfortable with productive disagreement. Listening does not mean accepting every opinion or avoiding difficult conversations. It means understanding an argument before responding to it. In a diverse workplace, that may involve hearing perspectives shaped by migration, culture, disability, caring responsibilities or regional life. Better decisions are often made when the room contains more than one version of reality.

Practices That Keep Me Curious

Replacing expert mode with curiosity is a practice rather than a personality change. I still have days when I interrupt, over-explain or reach for certainty too quickly. The difference is that I notice it sooner and can choose a different response. These are the habits I return to when I want to make more space for other people:

  • Ask one more open question before offering advice.
  • Let the other person finish, even when I think I know where the story is going.
  • Separate personal experience from professional expertise.
  • Say “I don’t know” without rushing to soften or justify it.
  • Invite disagreement from people with less power in the room.
  • Reflect on what I learned after a meeting, interview or presentation.
  • Give credit generously when an idea becomes stronger through someone else’s insight.

These habits have changed my understanding of leadership. The strongest person in a room is not necessarily the one with the fastest answer. It may be the person who creates enough trust for a quieter voice to speak, recognises the value in an unexpected perspective and knows when their role is to guide rather than perform.

That matters in every setting, from an intimate conversation at home to a large corporate event in Melbourne or Sydney. It matters during a challenging negotiation, a women’s leadership panel and a team discussion about mental health. People remember how informed a speaker was, but they also remember whether they felt seen, respected and able to participate.

I stopped trying to be the expert in every conversation because I wanted something more valuable than the appearance of certainty. I wanted real exchange. Knowledge still has a place in that exchange, as do preparation, conviction and clear advice. They simply work better when they are balanced by humility.

The most surprising result has been that listening has deepened my voice rather than diminished it. When I no longer need to prove that I belong in the room, I can be more present in it. I can speak with experience, make space for another perspective and leave with a fuller understanding than the one I arrived with.

A studio microphone on a stand in front of an audio mixing board, lit with deep red tones against a dark background, conveying a broadcast studio mood

On Air & In Print

Andrea anchors the ITV lunchtime talk show Loose Women, which she joined in 2007, following 11 years as a core presenter on ITV's breakfast programme GMTV, a role she left on New Year's Eve 2008.

Alongside broadcasting, she has written for Red, Best, Scottish Woman and numerous weekly women's titles since starting as a freelance travel writer in 1993.

See Press & Media

Reach & Recognition

A snapshot of the audience and impact behind Andrea's television, publishing and brand work.

5M Weekly viewers of Loose Women
1.5M Readers of her weekly home interior features in the Daily Mirror and Best Magazine, running since 2010
£1M+ Sales generated by her jewellery range, one of QVC's best-selling lines
View Full Stats

This Girl Is On Fire

Andrea is CEO and Co-founder of the female empowerment platform This Girl Is On Fire, built around a mission to help women live, learn and thrive in a life they love.

Explore the Platform

Screen & Studio

Promotional and broadcast work created for television and corporate partners, including Barclaycard, Vistaprint and Wii Fit U.

A dark flat-screen television glowing with warm light on a wooden media console in a dim room, calm and cinematic mood
A studio microphone on a stand in front of an audio mixing board, red backlighting, dark broadcast studio atmosphere
A sunlit wooden desk with a laptop, notebook, coffee mug and small potted plant, calm working atmosphere
Watch the Videos

Explore the Site

Find out more about Andrea's career, writing, media coverage and audience reach.

Get In Touch

For media, corporate or general enquiries, use the form below or reach out directly.

Contact details published on this site have appeared as +44 (0)20 7371 5444 / angharad.marsh@officialandreamclean.com and, on an earlier page, 020 7482 3282 / admin@officialandreamclean.com — please treat both as points of contact.